unintended consequences

Sometimes fiction speaks more effectively than anything that is objectively true. And never more so than in complex pastoral situations where no one (not even the poor pastor) can hold all the pieces.

So today, I offer a double book recommendation for the emotional unravelling of pastoral knots. But be warned: the books will take you through the pain rather than around it…

The first book is The Sparrow by Mary Doria Russell. (I know some of you have read it.)

The Sparrow imagines a world that moves between our own time and the not distant future. The premise is that a talented (if gangly) young scientist notices wave patterns from space that seem to be music, and therefore learns of life on another planet. This young man has a friend who is a Jesuit priest, and the Jesuit convinces the order to fund an exploratory journey into the new world.

The band of characters drawn together is immensely appealing. The awkward young scientist; the fervent Jesuit who believes he is called by God to this work; an earth-mother type and her husband, both of whom happen to be polymaths; and a beautiful and enigmatic Sephardic Jew (cue budding romance with gangly youth…)

The story is complex. The narrative’s ‘present’ is our future, in the midst of a Jesuit Inquisition. The priest is being tried for crimes against the other creatures, and he seems unable to defend himself.

But through the trial, you are given flashbacks. You follow the priest through all his discoveries, his optimism, his joy. And you are never sure whether he is sinner or saint.

Head and heart pull in opposite directions, then suddenly at the end, it makes a terrible sort of sense. It’s a stunning book that pushes you to think carefully about the nature of God, vocation, and ethics.

The books feels complete in itself. You may think you don’t want to read the sequel. But do. The second book is actually better — if also more painful.

The second book, Children of God, covers exactly the same story — but this time, the narrative moves between the Jesuits and the perspective of a life form that is indigenous to the planet. You see it all again: how the humans came, what the humans did, how their actions were received. And it is devastating.

Yes, the humans made mistakes. We knew that in the first book. Some of their actions had consequences they had never imagined. We knew that too.

But what catches you off guard is the complex way in which it was the very best of the human’s actions — their good intentions, their striving to get it right — that had the most damaging effect.

And that is so much easier to face in a novel than in a congregation, in someone else’s life than in our own.

The books are well worth a read. But don’t expect to feel like doing much afterwards.

p.s. — and if anyone out there knows where my copies are…

10 thoughts on “unintended consequences”

  1. Yes, The Sparrow!! One of my favorite books ever.

    I’m not so sure about The Children of God, I didn’t like that one nearly as much.

    But maybe I should give it another shot. Although it might have to wait until after the PhD. Or else a vacation – one long enough that I’ve gotten through the needing to read fluff stage and able to bite into something more chewy.

    Mary Doria Russel’s Thread of Grace is good too, although not as much as the others I didn’t think and very different (it’s set in Italy in WWII).

  2. I didn’t read Thread of Grace. The new one out last month looks more promising.

    You’re not the only one to prefer The Sparrow. A friend used to say to me, ‘you do pain well’, and it may be that only those of whom that could be said will prefer the second book.

  3. I haven’t yet dare pick up “Children of God” – “The Sparrow” exhausted me emotionally – I couldn’t read anything for ages afterwards! I have recommended it to my book group though (The Sparrow not CoG), with the same proviso I remember you giving me (“It’s science fiction but don’t let that put you off!”).

    Actually it kind of reminded me of the film “The Mission”, in that I thought it raised similar issues about the validity and impact of Christian ‘pioneer mission’.

    The title of this blog post is rather enigmatic!

  4. Did you give them to me years ago, or have you had them recently? I can’t remember how I acquired them, but you’re a likely candidate as giver. I gave mine to our library. Powerful stuff.

  5. Both Thread of Grace and the new one are now on my Amazon wish list – thanks for the heads up.

  6. Sarah, I’m coming home at the end of May. Maybe we can go book shopping after lunch? Are you free on Mon 26th? (or possibly Mon 2 June, though that is less good…) I’ll be in touch by email, but this way you can help me remember.

  7. On one cyber group, a religious one, we had a lassie who was a ‘witch’ and she came across as rather a nice person. However, she was converted back to the Christianity she had left. It was a particularly narrow kind of evangelicalism. She began to give the moderators, or whom I was one, a good deal of trouble, and they asked her to cool off a bit. She stomped off, only to return a year or so later, when we hoped she would be – shall we say more comfortable with herself? Well, she wasn’t. Or she was not more comfortable on the board. Certain things (usually attacks on fellow board members) ‘had to be said’ and she ended up banned. Christianity had made her fearful, or full of fear, and very angry.

    To my mind, she was closer to the likeness of Christ as a pagan than as a Christian.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s